top of page

How friction between two executives affects the wider team

4 minutes ago
5 min read

There are executive teams where, on the surface, everything appears reasonably functional. Meetings take place, decisions get made, and everyone behaves professionally. Yet something feels ‘off’, and a gradual erosion of performance and quality of relationships begins to creep in.

 

Sometimes, underneath all of this, there is a difficult relationship between just two members of the team. There may be history between them; perhaps they have fundamentally different views about the direction of the business, or trust may have been damaged somewhere along the way. Perhaps they simply find one another difficult.

 

The typical approach to resolve this involves seeing the problem as existing just between the two people, but this is often a mistake. Relationships in executive teams don't exist in isolation, and persistent tension between two executives can gradually reorganise the behaviour of everybody around them. The consequences of that pattern can become very damaging.

 

Teams adapt around warring pairs

 Imagine two influential senior executives who have developed a difficult relationship. One makes a proposal and, before responding, other members of the team glance across the table to see how the other will react. One person might moderate what they were going to say, another may make a conciliatory remark, somebody else who had a different topic on their mind might decide that perhaps now isn't the moment to raise the difficult issue they had planned to discuss, after all.

 

This is a profoundly limiting pattern that the team learns without a word being exchanged. Over time, people can become surprisingly skilful at doing this. As humans we are expert in anticipating reactions, avoiding particular subjects and working out who can say what to whom. Conversations start happening before the meeting to make sure the meeting goes smoothly, then other conversations happen afterwards because the real issue wasn't discussed during it. As a particularly astute client once said to me, “our business has quiet meetings and noisy corridors”.

 

On the surface meetings may look perfectly civil, but the team's intelligence is now being used to manage the team rather than the business.

 

This is why it is wise to keep an open mind when an executive team is described as having a problem with just a particular individual. When we think systemically, culturally, we look beyond ‘what is wrong with this person’ and inquire into the patterns occurring between people - including how everybody involved, usually with perfectly understandable intentions, might inadvertently be helping to maintain those patterns.

 

At Culture Impact, we help our clients to move from seeing problems simply as belonging to individuals, to noticing the relationships and patterns through which those problems are created and sustained.

 

Conflict isn't necessarily the problem

 None of this is to say that executive teams shouldn't experience conflict. It’s more worrying if a senior team apparently has no differences of opinion. When different people with different responsibilities, backgrounds, personalities, talents and ways of understanding the organisation come together, there should be disagreement. The more interesting question is what the team is capable of doing with it.

 

  • Can I disagree strongly with you without needing to defeat you?

  • Can you challenge my thinking without me experiencing that as an attack on my competence or authority?

  • Can we remain genuinely interested in what the other sees that we don't?

  • Can the rest of the team participate freely without finding themselves recruited, however subtly, onto one side or the other?

 

At some point, disagreement can become a recurring relational pattern. My behaviour affects yours, yours affects mine, and the meaning I make of your response influences what I do next. This gives you new evidence about me, and before long, each of us can become convinced that our behaviour is simply a reasonable response to the other's. But we don’t recognise how we are jointly creating something that neither of us actually wants.

 

These patterns can become self-sustaining, until people are able to examine what is happening and choose to respond differently.

 

When the relationship starts becoming cultural

 This issue is particularly important for CEOs, People Directors, and anyone responsible for executive effectiveness. Culture is shaped, in part, through repeated patterns of behaviour, and the executive team is one of the places where those patterns are created. What leaders encourage, discourage, and repeatedly tolerate are powerful creators of culture.

 

If people learn that certain tensions cannot be discussed, that becomes part of how the team works. If important conversations happen outside the room because they cannot happen inside it, or if colleagues become intermediaries between two executives who struggle to speak directly to one another, the original difficulty is no longer contained within one relationship.

 

Eventually organisations can begin experiencing consequences of these relational problems a long way away from their source. The problems leak. What appears to be an interpersonal difficulty may gradually be becoming an organisational pattern.

 

What has become undiscussable?

 There is another phenomenon you may recognise in executive teams around these issues. Very often everybody knows.

 

Nobody needs the tension explained to them - they can feel it, and they probably have their own interpretation of how it arose and who is responsible. Yet something obvious to almost everybody can become increasingly difficult to name. Almost every executive team will have things that are easier not to discuss. But that silence comes at a cost.

 

The pattern can change

 The objective is effectiveness, but relationships are part of effectiveness. An executive team needs to think together, challenge one another, coordinate action, and make difficult decisions - particularly when pressure increases. If a recurring relational pattern interferes with that capacity, working on the pattern is business work.

 

These patterns can change, but first they need to become visible. This is where skilled external facilitation can help. Find some support that can help the executives and the wider team notice something that is hard to see when you’re inside it: what pattern are you creating together?

 

When the pattern is visible, different questions become possible.

 

  • What am I contributing to this?

  • What happens elsewhere in the team when we interact in this way?

  • What conversation have we learnt not to have?

  • What might become possible if we had it?

 

When a team gets skilful at noticing its own patterns, they take a powerful step in their development. That inevitably has a positive impact on performance. What looked like a problem is often revealed to be a capability that the team just needed to develop, for example, being able to disagree productively, talk about difficult relationships, clarify authority, or notice its own patterns before they get entrenched.

 

If you’re beginning to notice a relationship in your executive team that everyone has learned to work around, look beyond the two people who look most like ‘the problem’. What has this relationship started to create in the team around them? And what are you ready to do about it?

 

At Culture Impact, we support executives and the teams around them through pair coaching, team coaching and executive team development. If this feels familiar, get in touch to explore how we can help your team notice the patterns holding it back and find a different way of working together.

Comments


bottom of page